{
  "schema": 1,
  "study_id": "type-delimiter-before-word",
  "revision": "editing200-r03",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-09-17T19:35:00Z",
  "packet_url": "https://6f395797.openai-film-fieldnotes-100.pages.dev/",
  "verdict": "B",
  "confidence": "moderate",
  "source_label": "A",
  "candidate_label": "B",
  "source_sha256": "a3f8d257ba7baee09db9d1c3b006282dcffeb962f6bd4be616b74cf58a25e3b8",
  "candidate_sha256": "4bed28e0e5692ba2b4249ae2f5eb1b187e309495ee32912ed08912c75d5edd4d",
  "blindness": "Fresh critic received only the randomized neutral packet. Source code, identities, answer key and prior reports were withheld until the final verdict.",
  "reason": "The remake's delimiter spacing stays more coherent as the words develop. Wider natural letterforms integrate better with the punctuation. Centering, reveal order and final hold did not provide a meaningful advantage.",
  "largest_comparison_gap": "At frame 112 the original closing parenthesis crowds the final n; at frame 99 it leaves excess trailing space. The critic preferred the remake's substring-dependent advance over equal per-character steps.",
  "measurements_reported_by_critic": {
    "frame_112_same_row_ink_gap_px": {"A": 4, "B": 22},
    "complete_phrase_first_frame": 116,
    "hold_frames": 70
  },
  "playback_evidence": {
    "tool": "T3 collaborative browser",
    "rate": 1,
    "ended_both": true,
    "end_time_seconds": 3.1,
    "reported_dropped_frames": {"A": 0, "B": 0},
    "scope": "Successful playback execution, not continuous visual observation. Snapshots and recording failed before the preview host became unavailable."
  },
  "visual_evidence": "All 186 frames per film decoded. Consecutive frames 0–123 inspected, the remainder sampled, and all 70 hold frames checked for unchanged thresholded text geometry. Critical frames inspected at native 1920×1080.",
  "remaining_limits": [
    "Agent editorial preference, not human viewing certification or official OpenAI approval.",
    "Licensed substitute typeface and authored punctuation differ from the source.",
    "Only retained original excerpt bytes and clock are verified; inherited full-film interval was not reverified.",
    "Resolve instructions are supplied; native Resolve execution remains untested."
  ],
  "prior_rounds": [
    {"revision": "editing200-r01", "verdict": "original preferred", "gap": "Connector compressed and too far from its bracket."},
    {"revision": "editing200-r02", "verdict": "original preferred", "gap": "Deployment lettering compressed beside the parentheses."}
  ],
  "credit": {"accepted_studies": 1, "new_source_ranges": 0, "alternate_copy_credit": 0}
}